• 0 Posts
  • 123 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: July 2nd, 2023

help-circle




  • PLAGUEIS.

    Okay so is Darth Bortles Plagueis’s apprentice, or is Plagueis hunting down Darth Bortles?

    Are we to understand that Osha/Mae are the blueprint that Plagueis uses to learn to create life, the experiment that leads to the creation of Anakin?

    I like the idea that Osha/Mae were able to be created because they are balanced. One is light while one is dark. As Mae learns to forgive, Osha is pushed to the dark side. And while Osha was training to be a Jedi, Mae agreed to be Darth Bortles’s acolyte immediately.

    Plagueis attempting to create and prolong life from the Dark alone triggers, accidentally, the Force to create Anakin to bring balance. IIRC that’s what we see in the book Plagueis, which is of course no longer canon.


  • I don’t think anyone who sat down and watched through the first 3 episodes can honestly say the show is being review bombed.

    I can understand why people decided after the third episode that the show was bad, but I think that reaction was short-sighted and impatient.

    A lot of the reviews decrying the third episode completely miss what I thought was very obvious in that episode: we were seeing the events through a single perspective, that of a child who is missing a significant amount of context. The “plot holes” are on purpose, to make the audience say, “Nah, that doesn’t add up.” Because it doesn’t.

    Sure enough, in episode 7 we see the same events from more perspectives and, surprise, it makes a lot more sense. We get to see through the lies of the Jedi.

    I’m not trying to say The Acolyte is perfect, but it’s a damn sight better than 3/10 or whatever IMDB has it as right now. And it brought a lot of cool stuff from Legends onto the screen.

    I enjoyed the ride. The easter eggs were fun, the fight choreography was as solid, and Manny Jacinto is amazing.







  • After 4 episodes, I am now convinced we’ve seen the best this show has to offer and it’s only going to get worse.

    I dunno about you, but I thought episode 5 was awesome. Also I’m really excited to see the other side of the story we saw in episode 3. I suspect this show will be better as a binge rather than weekly, because we’ve been burned enough times that we’re quick to assume plot holes are mistakes rather than purposeful setup.

    This isn’t the best Star Wars show, but I’m liking it.